“We believe that God has created the entire cosmos; our work here is to say, 'This belongs to God,' and to help point out the beauty of creation to everyone we know, everyone we meet. And most of all, to live in it ourselves” (Chris Seay, The Gospel of John, 63).
Seay acknowledges God as the Creator as do almost all Emerging Church proponents, but notice his next statement. Is our central task to tell everyone that this is God’s creation and to point out its beauty during the process? W...
Read More
Should Christians Work Together to Glorify Christ Regardless of Their Faith Tradition?
“Postmodern churches are both Catholic and evangelical” (49). “[W]e welcome people from all faith backgrounds to come alongside us in Christ, whether their heritage is Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox, or other” (Michael Slaughter and Warren Bird, Unlearning Church, 9).
This type of church is very appealing to a postmodern culture. It holds theology, exclusive truth claims, and individual doctrine very loosely and prefers to emphasize community and good works. But how can community and go...
Read More
Does the Sacred and Secular Meet in Christ’s Incarnation? – A Response to Michael Slaughter and Warren Bird
“Incarnation is the place where sacred and secular meet” (Michael Slaughter and Warren Bird, Unlearning Church, 51).
Is it? Christ is Holy as is the human flesh that he received during His incarnation. The human flesh was good in the eyes of God until it became stained by the sinfulness of humanity. But Christ’s flesh remained good because of His immaculate conception. It seems dangerous for the Emerging Church to be welding the sacred with the secular in the Person of Christ. Ins...
Read More
The Meaningless of Pluralism – A Response to Samir Selmanovic
“To say that God has decided to visit all humanity through only one particular religion is a deeply unsatisfying assertion about God” (Samir Selmanovic, It’s Really All about God, 9). Before we consider this assertion, here are some notable authors who recommended this book: Marcus Borg, Brian McLaren, and Paul Knitter.When we say that God has revealed Himself to humanity through a particular religion, we are making this claim based on Scripture. The Bible either is or is not divinely inspired....
Read More
Are People Capable of ‘Good’ Works without Christ? – A Response to Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch
“We need to seriously get over Christendom’s theological cringe factor regarding the value of human goodness (dualism again?). We don’t have to denigrate genuine goodness in order to glorify God. James says that all good things come from God and have their source in God (1:17) and so it does not denigrate God when we say that some human acts are good. If someone sacrifices his or her life or possessions to help someone else, then we must affirm that it is in itself a good act. It has intrinsic ...
Read More
Do Exclusivists Go to Hell? – A Response to Michael Hardin
Michael Hardin’s book, from which the following quote is taken, is forwarded by Brian McLaren, who “appreciated Michael’s approach to Scripture” (Michael Hardin, xiii, The Jesus Driven Life). Hardin writes, “Because for Jesus, God is inclusive and reaches out to those whom the religious had consigned to an eternity of being roasted over a devilish fire like marshmallows. Those who consign others to hell will, in the end, get the god they have believed in” (Ibid.,44).
Certainly, most conserva...
Read More
Intolerance? – The Case for Debate as an Entertainment Medium
"He's said to be a Buddhist -- I don't think that faith offers the kind of forgiveness and redemption that is offered by the Christian faith," said Brit Hume. Then he added, "So my message to Tiger would be: Tiger, turn to the Christian faith and you can make a total recovery and be a great example to the world" (Brit Hume, This quote is found on many websites).
Hume’s comments appear to be a Christian exclusivist view (Jesus is the only way). In response, he was blasted across the media for...
Read More
Is Hell Real? – A Response to Love Wins by Rob Bell
Rob Bell provides a helpful insight into how he views the Scripture: “The ancient sages said the words of the sacred text were black letters on a white page—there’s all that white space, waiting to be filled with our responses and discussions and debates and opinions and longings and desires and wisdom and insights” (Love Wins, x). Here, Bell exalts human opinion and diminishes divine inspiration of the Scriptures. Bell’s low view of Scripture and high view of human opinion (including his) shou...
Read More
Simplistic Dismissals of Theological Concepts
"The problem, however, is that the phrase 'personal relationship' is found nowhere in Scripture" (Rob Bell, Love Wins, 10).
Bell is correct when he says “personal relationship” does not appear in the Bible, but how does this fact support his argument against the necessity of a personal relationship with Christ? His book, Love Wins, contains a lengthy discussion on the nonexistence of hell. What if we responded to Bell that his argument, his discussion, his beliefs, etc. in the book are ...
Read More
Should evangelism resonate?
For Pagitt, the “guiding idea of evangelism is not change” or “conversion. It’s resonance” (Doug Pagitt, Evangelism in the Inventive Age, 9). In Matthew 18:3 (NIV 1984), Jesus says “I tell you the truth, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven.” In Mark 1:15 (NIV 1984), Jesus says, “The time has come, the kingdom of God is near. Repent and believe the good news!” In Luke 5:32 (NIV 1984), Jesus says, “I have not come to call the righteous, bu...
Read More