This bibliography contains many (and most) books written by Emerging/Emergent Church proponents. In addition, it contains many (and most) books by critics of the Emerging/Emergent Church. A few additional books deal more directly with postmodernism, pluralism, and relativism and were added because of their relevance in regard to the study of the Emerging Church.Anderson, Ray S. AnEmergent Theology for Emerging Churches. Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2006.Bass, Diane Butler. ThePractici...
Read More
Comments on Leonard Sweet’s “Out of the Question . . . Into the Mystery”
The following comments come from excerpts from Leonard Sweet’s Out of the Question . . . Into the Mystery.
Quote 1: “The modern church has a propositional attitude rather than a relational attitude” (30).
Granted, no church should approach Jesus with the heart of a Pharisee that thinks one can earn one’s relationship with God. Nor can one take on a Gnostic attitude that search for a secret knowledge, propositional or otherwise, should be a means to access God. Sweet would ...
Read More
Christianity, Zen Buddhism, and New Age Philosophy
Dogen, a 13th century patriarch of the Soto Zen school (see Smith and Novak's Buddhism: A Concise Intro.) said, “In pursuit of the Way, the prime essential is [meditation]. Just to pass time in sitting straight, without any thought of acquisition, without any sense of achieving enlightenment—this is the way of the patriarchs. It is true that our predecessors recommended both the koan [a meaningless phrase] and sitting, but it was the sitting they particularly insisted upon. ...
Read More
Leonard Sweet’s Soul Tsunami
Leonard Sweet writes, "Invitation to discipleship is not made through propositions or arguments, but with feelings, moods, music, and energy" (Soul Tsunami, 215).
How can we communicate the gospel of Jesus Christ apart from propositional truths? Some in the Emerging Church argue that the gospel should be communicated through actions and stories. Obviously, actions alone will fail to communicate the gospel alone. The actions of Jesus Himself were misinterpreted by many of the Jews. As far as ...
Read More
A Logical Fallacy from ReJesus by Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch
"The Hellenists used a tightly contained step logic whereby one would argue from premise to conclusion; each step in the process is linked tightly to the next in a coherent, rational, linear fashion. “The conclusion, however, was usually limited to one point of view - the human being’s perception of reality’” In contrast, Hebraic thinking tended to express concepts in self-contained units, or blocks, of thought. The blocks did not necessarily fit together in an obviously linear or harmonious pa...
Read More
Jesus as Truth in Leonard Sweet and Frank Viola’s Jesus Manifesto
Leonard Sweet and Frank Viola contend that "According to Scripture, Jesus Christ (and not a doctrine about Him) is the truth. In addition, Jesus Christ (and not an ethic derived from His teaching) is the way. In other words, both God's truth and God's way are embodied in a living, breathing person--Christ" (Jesus Manifesto, 80).
Here, Sweet and Viola make a marvelous point--Christianity is a relationship with Christ as opposed to a set impersonal guidelines. Even so, their approach to making...
Read More
Leonard Sweet’s AquaChurch – A Church without a Solid Foundation
According to Leonard Sweet, "God speaks to humans through the human. All divine revelation is culturally mediated. This means that the Bible must be metabolized through the passions and polemics of the culture in which it will be lived out" (AquaChurch, 56).
Okay, the Bible was certainly written by human agents, but those agents were inspired by the Holy Spirit. The Bible, therefore, speaks to humans through a Spirit-inspired human agency.
Sweet admits that the Bible is divine revelation,...
Read More
Kingdom and/or King – A Response to Rick McKinley
"The news of the Kingdom was, in fact, the primary message of Jesus" (Rick McKinley, This Beautiful Mess, 30).
This statement represents a major component of Emerging Church theology. In the context of McKinley's statement, he makes the case for the gospel accounts being the primary teaching of Christ and His Kingdom. Certainly, the Gospels record Christ's actions and words, but the remainder of the New Testament offers spiritual insight into the meaning and application of those w...
Read More
A Bit of Panentheism in the Emerging Church
According to Tony Jones, "panentheism . . . is evident in the practices of the emerging church movement" (The Church is Flat, 165). He further states that these practices serve to eliminate the divide between the sacred and the secular (Ibid., 166).
Donald Miller offers one example: “I once listened to an Indian on television say that God was in the wind and the water, and I wondered at how beautiful that was because it meant you could swim in Him or have Him brush your face in a breeze...
Read More
Comments on Organic Community by Joseph Myers
"Our focus should be on the journey, not the destination" (Myers, Organic Community, 32).
Is Myers correct? Should our focus be on the journey? The invitation to journey with Jesus is found in many emerging church writings and even evangelical churches often invite people to begin the journey. All Christians who accept Christ's call to follow Him are called undertake the journey along the narrow path. Even so, are Christians to focus on this journey or the destination to which they are ...
Read More